At Ashtaroth, John found a man teaching beneath a fig press.
The man had never sat with the Twelve. He had never worked at the camp. When he used Yeshua’s name, John stopped him.
“Who gave you leave?”
“A man at Kheresa.”
“Which man?”
“Amos.”
John had heard the pieces. The fevered mind. The dogs that had followed Yeshua. The swine already running toward the cliff. By sundown they had become one story.
“Amos is not one of us.”
“He was there.”
“That is not the same.”
The man wiped fig pulp from his hands.
“It was enough for me.”
That evening at Gamala, John reported him to Yeshua.
“I forbade him.”
“Why?”
“He does not follow us.”
“He follows the work.”
“He says things badly.”
“So do you.”
The men around the fire looked down.
“His name is Mattan,” John said. “He claims your name without knowing you.”
“A cup of water does not ask who authorized the hand.”
John picked a fig seed from the heel of his palm.
“Then anyone may teach.”
“Anyone may be wrong. Do not make that your property either.”
At first light John returned to the fig press. Mattan was scraping yesterday’s pulp from the stone. The teaching stool stood upside down beneath the tree. John set it upright.
“Continue.”
He took the scraper and worked the other side of the press while the first listeners came.
On the sixteenth day of September the company returned to Magadan. Andrew suspended the week’s work. Ten apostles left for their homes or friends. Thomas stayed because a Greek had arrived with questions. Nathanael had tied his bag for Cana.
“Stay,” Thomas said.
Nathanael put the bag beneath the meeting table. Rhodon of Alexandria wore a plain travel cloak over a tunic cut by a more expensive hand. Yeshua received him at the edge of camp.
“I came to put my questions to you,” Rhodon said.
Yeshua called Thomas and Nathanael.
“Give them your questions. Hear their answers. Make them earn better ones.”
Two dozen believers gathered the first morning to hear Rhodon. He stood among them rather than in front.
“Your teacher says the Father is a person.”
Thomas nodded.
“Then define person without making God a large man.”
Thomas pulled a stool into the shade.
“Sit.”
Rhodon did.
“That is not an answer.”
“You have been standing since sunrise.”
For three days they carried the question through meals, washing, and the repair of a roof cloth torn by wind. Rhodon held one corner while Nathanael climbed.
“A person communicates,” Rhodon said.
“So does a trumpet,” Thomas answered.
“A person understands another person.”
“A dog understands hunger.”
“Then give me the difference.”
Thomas tied the roof line and looked down.
“I have used the word longer than I have understood it.”
Rhodon smiled. “Now we can begin.”
The next morning Rhodon spoke to the two dozen believers. He did not begin with God. He began with a broken partnership in Alexandria.
Two men had owned ships together. One trusted contracts, the other trusted kin. When a cargo disappeared, each protected the thing he called trust until the partnership could no longer carry either man.
“A civilization is only this problem made large,” Rhodon said. “Men living together without agreeing what makes a man worth trusting.”
A fisherman near the wall said, “The law.”
“Which law?”
The fisherman named Moses. A Greek dyer named the city court. A woman from the camp named the promise made when no witness stood nearby.
Rhodon turned to Thomas. “Your answer?”
“Watch what the man does after the cargo is gone.”
“That tells you his character.”
“That is what I would trust.”
Rhodon looked toward Nathanael.
“And you?”
“Watch whether he still calls the other man brother.”
The fisherman laughed. “Then trust no one.”
Nathanael handed him the torn roof cloth.
“Hold this.”
The wind pulled it from the man’s first grip. On the second attempt, four people lifted together and fastened it. Rhodon waited until they sat.
“You built no law,” he said.
“We built a roof,” Thomas said.
At supper Rhodon unfolded a letter from a friend in Alexandria who had stopped answering after Rhodon joined Abner’s men. The seal had been broken and pressed shut again so many times that the wax no longer held.
“He said I had traded philosophy for a Galilean.”
“Did you?” Nathanael asked.
Rhodon folded bread around an olive.
“That is why I came. I have written six answers.”
“How many have you sent?” Thomas asked.
“None.”
“Then your friend has not stopped answering.”
Rhodon looked up.
“He has answered the last letter he received,” Thomas said.
Nathanael reached for the wine. “The wall.”
Rhodon laughed and put the letter away. On the following morning, Yeshua handed Rhodon a water jar.
“Walk with them.”
He left for the hills.
Rhodon watched him go. “He refuses the argument.”
“He gave it to us,” Nathanael said.
“Why?”
Thomas lifted the second jar.
“Perhaps he trusts poor work.”
“Or expects it.”
They carried water to the women’s infirmary.
Salma stopped them at the entrance. “If the philosopher can argue, he can wash cups.”
Rhodon washed.
A man in the nearest tent had refused food for two days. He would take it only from one attendant and cursed every other person who approached. Thomas tried reason. Nathanael tried humor. Rhodon sat outside the tent with the bowl between his feet.
“My friend stopped writing to me,” he said through the cloth. “I keep composing answers.”
The man inside said nothing. Rhodon ate one spoonful. After a while a hand came through the opening and took the bowl.
Later the man came out to wash. He recognized Rhodon’s accent.
“Alexandria?”
“Yes.”
“I worked the grain ships.”
Rhodon took the cup he had cleaned and gave it to him. The man drank.
“Which dock?”
They spoke until the wash water cooled.
That night Rhodon unrolled his notes.
“If the Father is a person, why make beings who cannot understand him?”
Nathanael took the reed.
“A child does not understand a father before he can speak.”
“That proves growth. It does not prove personality.”
Thomas took the reed from Nathanael and drew a line beneath the question.
“Leave that one.”
“Until when?”
Thomas laid the reed across the blank space. Before the lamps went out, Rhodon turned to a clean place on the papyrus.
“Peter calls him the Son of the living God. Why do you call him more than a man?”
Thomas rubbed dried clay from the rim of the cup he had washed.
“I have watched him when no crowd remained. He does not ask the Father to become willing.”
“A man can trust God.”
“He knows the Father before he prays.”
Rhodon looked at Nathanael.
“And you?”
“I have watched every enemy offer him a smaller man to become.”
“That makes him the best of men.”
Nathanael nodded. “Begin there.”
Rhodon wrote nothing in the clean space.
On the seventh day Yeshua returned.
Rhodon met him at the edge of camp. “They disagree.”
“Often.”
“Thomas reaches a wall and names it. Nathanael walks around it and says the view has changed.”
“Which helped you?”
Rhodon looked at the infirmary. The man in the tent had come out and was washing his own bowl.
“The wall.”
The next morning Yeshua and ten apostles left for Jerusalem.
Thomas and Nathanael remained at the table with Rhodon. His notes lay between them, still open to the question and the blank lines beneath it.