By the third week Vidar had stopped writing down what the philosophers said and started writing down how long they could say it.
He sat at the edge of the painted porch and made a mark for each man who rose to speak and a second mark when the man sat down. The Greeks could hold a question longer than other men can hold a breath. Other men turn colors and let go. The Greeks did not turn any color at all. They had a word for everything. They had three words for some things, and would spend a morning on which of the three a fourth thing wanted.
He wrote in his book: Today they asked what the good is. They were asking it before I came. I think they are afraid of the day they answer it.
His teacher had said nothing in three weeks. He came to the porch each morning and listened, where every other man was only waiting his turn to speak. When a thing was said well his face moved. When a thing was said only to win, he went still. He did not rise and he did not take a side, and after a while the silence of him became a thing in the porch, and the men argued toward him without meaning to, watching the carpenter on the step to see whether what they had said had moved his face.
One of them could not bear it.
His name was Theron. He had come to Athens from a city on the far western sea to finish himself, and he was nearly finished, and he was the best of them, and he knew it because he had written it down. He kept a tablet across his knee and a stylus in his hand, and when he said a thing he believed true he wrote it as he said it, so that he was the only man in the porch who went home each evening with the morning in his hand. He had filled forty tablets that way. He wrote everything down because he had watched his own father, at the end, lose the words for things, the names of tools and then the names of his own sons, and had sworn that nothing he knew would go the same way. He had never once written another man’s sentence.
“You.” Theron said it to the carpenter on a morning the talk had worn thin. “You sit in the one place on earth where every man says what he knows, and you say nothing. Either you have nothing, or you are keeping it. Which of the two insults us more I have not decided.”
“I am listening,” the carpenter said. “I came a long way to hear this. It would be rude to talk.”
A few of them laughed. Theron did not. He wrote something on his tablet, and it was not that.
That night the boy could not sleep. He took the book to the lamp and read his own pages back.
Two years of them. In every country the road had crossed he had written down the names men gave their God: Egypt’s, Persia’s, the islands’, Carthage’s, Rome’s, a page for each people, the name at the head of it. He had set out to gather every name there was and carry them all home in the one book, and Athens, which kept a god for everything, was filling the last of his pages. Only one line had stayed empty. The first line of the first page, under no nation, the line he had ruled for the highest name of all. Nothing he had found in two years on the road was big enough to write there.
He read the names back, all of them. Some he could no longer say aloud. He had written them down and moved on, and not one of them had he ever prayed.
He thought about the man who would read the book when it was finished, a man who would know the name of God in every tongue on the earth. And he wondered whether that man would stand one step nearer to God than the old woman two doors down at home, who knew no name at all, and set out bread for the dead on the right night, and went to her sleep easy.
He turned to a clean page and wrote, in the careful hand he kept for the sentences that mattered.
There was a man who wanted the true name of God. He went to every country and wrote down what each people called him. He filled one book and started another. He grew old on the road, still writing. One evening he came to a well.
The boy stopped. He did not know how it ended. He sat with the stylus over the page and the man at the well and no ending in him, and after a while he closed the book on the unfinished line and lay down and did not sleep.
In the afternoons the porch let out, and the boy took his teacher through the city to gather the last of the names. Athens was a harvest. They had a god for the sea and a god for the grain, a god for the line between one man’s field and the next, a god for the hour the new wine was opened, and each one had a house and a carved name. The boy filled three pages and was not done.
Near the foot of the great rock, on the road down to the harbor, they came to an altar smaller than the rest. It was old, the stone rubbed pale by hands. There was no image on it and no name cut into it.
“It has no god,” the boy said.
A seller of incense was folding his stall beside it. “It has the one we forgot,” he said, not unkindly, telling a child a thing his city had long stopped finding strange. “When the plague came and none of the named gods lifted it, the fathers built that one. For the god whose name we do not have. In case the trouble was that we had never once called him.”
The boy wrote Athens at the head of a clean page and set the names under it, the sea and the grain and the boundary and the wine. For the nameless altar he left a blank line and put no word on it.
His teacher stood with his hand flat on the pale stone of the altar a while. Then he took it back, and they went on.
Theron came at him a last time the day before they were to leave. He had not let the silence go. Three weeks it had sat in his porch and he had filled four tablets arguing around it, and it had not so much as leaned. He found the carpenter in the market with the boy and did not soften it.
“Tomorrow you carry your nothing back to your village,” Theron said. “Leave me one thing first. You have heard the best of us for a month. Tell me one true thing you did not hear in this city. One. Then go.”
The carpenter set down the bread he had been buying.
“There was a man who set out to learn the true name of God,” he said.
The boy went still beside him.
“He went to every country and wrote down what each people called him. He filled one book and started another. He grew old on the road. One evening he came to a well in a country whose name for God he did not yet have, and he sat down to write it before he forgot it. A girl drawing water held the cup out to him, and he waved her off, because he had not finished. He wrote until the light failed. In the dark he could not find the cup. In the morning they found him at the well with the book full and the cup dry, a step from the water, every name for God in his hand.”
Theron waited for the rest. For the half that would turn the first half into a thing a man could answer.
There was no rest.
The stylus was in his hand. He did not write. The boy had crouched beside the carpenter with his own book open on his knee, and Theron saw, upside down across the boy’s knee, the same man and the same well in a child’s hand, broken off with no ending under it, set down the night before the carpenter ever opened his mouth.
Theron looked at the boy’s page a long time.
Then he wrote, on his own tablet, for the first time in his life another man’s words. He got the well right and the book right. He wrote that the man died of thirst, which the carpenter had not said. Theron was a man who finished things.
The carpenter watched him close the tablet and did not reach over and open it again.
They left Athens by the eastern road and Theron by the western, two mornings apart, and the city forgot the silent man, his place on the step taken by another before noon.
The boy kept his book. He did not finish the line he had broken off at the well. He left it open, under the man and the water, and on the page across from it, where a name should have gone, he drew a cup.
His teacher looked at the cup a while. Then he put his hand on the back of the boy’s neck and held it there, as his own father had once held his, and said nothing, and the boy let him, and they went east with the book between them.
On the western water Theron stood at the rail and told the story to whoever would hold still for it. He told it as he had written it, the man dead of thirst at the well, and the sailors listened, and the ship carried it west, toward a city the carpenter would never see.